Should You Worry About Crime in Buffalo NY? A Local’s Perspective

When planning a move or visit to any city, safety is a top concern—and Buffalo, NY is no exception. If you're wondering is Buffalo NY safe, you're not alone. As a longtime local who has lived through the highs and lows of the Queen City, I’m here to offer an honest and practical look at crime in Buffalo and what it really means for residents and visitors.

Understanding the Reality: Is Buffalo NY Safe?

Buffalo has seen its fair share of challenges over the years, from economic downturns to rising crime rates in certain neighbourhoods. However, it’s important to note that crime in Buffalo isn’t spread evenly across the city. Like many urban areas in the U.S., Buffalo has safe neighbourhoods and others that are considered high-risk.

While some national rankings paint a concerning picture, the real experience on the ground often tells a more nuanced story.

What the Crime Statistics Really Say?

When analyzing crime data, it’s important to break it down:

• Property Crime: This includes burglary, theft, and motor vehicle theft. Buffalo’s property crime rate is higher than the national average, but not drastically different from other large cities in New York.

• Violent Crime: Buffalo does have pockets of higher violent crime, particularly in certain East Side neighborhoods. However, these incidents are typically concentrated and not widespread across the entire city.

• Trends: Over the last decade, Buffalo has seen periods of rising and falling crime. Recent community-driven initiatives and increased police presence have contributed to reductions in some areas.

  
  

Safe Neighborhoods in Buffalo You Should Know

Despite the headlines, there are many neighborhoods in Buffalo that are widely considered safe, welcoming, and vibrant.

Here are a few:

• Elmwood Village – Known for its walkability, coffee shops, boutiques, and tree-lined streets. A favorite for young professionals and families.

• North Buffalo – A quiet, residential area with parks, schools, and family-friendly amenities.

• South Buffalo – Traditionally Irish-American, this neighborhood is known for strong community ties and relatively low crime.

• West Side (near Grant-Ferry) – A rapidly revitalizing area, home to diverse communities and artistic energy. Safety has improved greatly in recent years.

• Parkside – Located near Delaware Park and the Buffalo Zoo, Parkside is one of the city’s most picturesque and stable areas.

Local Tips for Staying Safe in Buffalo

Whether you're visiting or relocating, here are some common-sense tips to stay safe:

• Stay aware of your surroundings, especially at night.

• Avoid walking alone in unfamiliar neighborhoods after dark.

• Lock your car and secure valuables—property crimes like car break-ins are more common than violent crimes.

• Use ride-share or public transportation in less familiar areas.

• Talk to locals—Buffalo residents are generally warm and happy to share neighborhood insights.

• Follow community groups or local news to stay updated on current events and safety trends.

The Community Effort to Improve Safety

Buffalo is a city that cares deeply about its people. Neighborhood watch programs, community centers, and local nonprofits are working hard to make the city safer for everyone. Organizations like Buffalo Peacemakers and Back to Basics Outreach Ministries are tackling youth violence and promoting alternatives to crime through education and mentorship.

Furthermore, the city government is investing in lighting, surveillance, and police reforms that prioritize transparency and community trust.

Wrapping Up

So, is Buffalo NY safe? The answer depends on where you go and how aware you are. Like any city, it has its issues—but it also has strong communities, cultural pride, and ongoing efforts to improve.

As a local, I walk my dog through Elmwood Village at night, attend community events on the West Side, and feel proud of how far our city has come. Awareness is key, but fear doesn't need to define your experience here. Buffalo is a city on the rise—with a heart as big as its lake.

If you're considering a visit or move, don’t let crime statistics alone make your decision. Come see Buffalo for yourself—you might just fall in love with its charm, resilience, and sense of community.